← All articles

CULTURE / A QUESTION OF TIMING

Christmas Movie Trivia: Which Came First?

You know the traps, the train and the Christmas disasters. But can you remember which movie came first?

Christmas Movie Trivia: Which Came First? Three festive quiz cards show a wreath-covered door, a snowy steam train, and a Santa hat with cinema popcorn.

Was Kevin defending his house before Buddy left the North Pole? Had the Muppets met Scrooge before Tim Allen put on the red suit?

Your Christmas watchlist probably puts these films side by side. Their release years tell a different story.

Try these six Christmas movie trivia questions. Pick the earlier film in each pair, then open Reveal answer to check the years. Give yourself one point for every correct choice: six points available, no exact dates required.

We're comparing the original US theatrical release years of the specific films named. Sequels, later rereleases and earlier adaptations don't count.

Start with the holiday regulars

1. Home Alone or Elf?

A. Home Alone, with Macaulay Culkin as Kevin
B. Elf, with Will Ferrell as Buddy

Reveal answer

A — Home Alone.

Home Alone: 1990. Elf: 2003.

Kevin had a thirteen-year head start on Buddy. Both feel like permanent fixtures of December, but they arrived in different decades.

Sources: 20th Century Studios' Home Alone page · AFI's Elf record.

2. The Polar Express or Jim Carrey's Grinch?

A. The Polar Express, the animated train journey with Tom Hanks
B. How the Grinch Stole Christmas, the live-action film with Jim Carrey

Reveal answer

B — How the Grinch Stole Christmas.

How the Grinch Stole Christmas: 2000. The Polar Express: 2004.

The green fur came before the golden ticket. This comparison uses Carrey's live-action Grinch, rather than the earlier television special or the later animated feature.

Sources: Peacock's How the Grinch Stole Christmas page · AFI's The Polar Express record.

3. The Santa Clause or The Muppet Christmas Carol?

A. The Santa Clause, with Tim Allen as Scott Calvin
B. The Muppet Christmas Carol, with Michael Caine as Scrooge

Reveal answer

B — The Muppet Christmas Carol.

The Muppet Christmas Carol: 1992. The Santa Clause: 1994.

The Muppets got to Christmas two years before Scott Calvin's unexpected career change. If you remember both as part of the same childhood, this is where the timeline starts separating those memories.

Sources: Disney D23's The Muppet Christmas Carol entry · D23's The Santa Clause entry.

Now try the double-feature decisions

4. Love Actually or The Holiday?

A. Love Actually, the ensemble film with Hugh Grant and Emma Thompson
B. The Holiday, the house-swap romance with Cameron Diaz and Kate Winslet

Reveal answer

A — Love Actually.

Love Actually: 2003. The Holiday: 2006.

The interlocking love stories came three years before the house swap. Here's a bonus connection to question one: Love Actually and Elf share a release year. Your grown-up Christmas rewatch and your family comedy can belong to the same moment in film history.

Sources: AFI's Love Actually record · Sony's The Holiday page.

5. Christmas Vacation or Scrooged?

A. National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation, with Chevy Chase as Clark Griswold
B. Scrooged, with Bill Murray as television executive Frank Cross

Reveal answer

B — Scrooged.

Scrooged: 1988. Christmas Vacation: 1989.

Just one year separates these two Christmas disasters. Murray's modern Scrooge arrived first; the Griswolds followed the next holiday season. This is the closest pair in the quiz.

Sources: Paramount's Scrooged page · AFI's Christmas Vacation record.

6. Arthur Christmas or the animated Grinch?

A. Arthur Christmas, about Santa's son and a missed present
B. Illumination's animated The Grinch, voiced by Benedict Cumberbatch

Reveal answer

A — Arthur Christmas.

Arthur Christmas: 2011. The Grinch: 2018.

Arthur's delivery mission came seven years before this Grinch. Keeping the two Grinch films straight is half the challenge: Jim Carrey's version belongs near the start of the 2000s, while the animated feature arrives much later.

Sources: Sony's Arthur Christmas page · Illumination's The Grinch page.

How did you do?

  • 6/6: You can organize the Christmas movie marathon.
  • 4–5/6: You know your festive films. A couple of years need rearranging.
  • 2–3/6: Your watchlist is doing some time travel.
  • 0–1/6: An excellent excuse for a rewatch.

Send a friend your score: “I got __/6 on Christmas movie trivia. Can you beat me?” Let them choose before showing them the answers.

Can you put five in order?

Picking the earlier of two films is the warm-up. Keeping five pop-culture moments in order is where the second-guessing starts.

Play today's PopLine for five rounds of timeline trivia. Drag the events from earliest to latest, check your order, then see the dates. It's free, with no signup needed.

Try another quiz: Video Game Trivia: Which Came First?